Views
Mbatha v. Cutting: Implications for Litigants of Indian Origin
Guest Post by Chytanya S. Agarwal*
I. Introduction
Rising cross-border migration of people and concomitant increase in lawsuits relating to matrimonial disputes between couples brings to the forefront the issue of conflict of jurisdictional laws (219th Law Commission Report, ¶1.1-¶1.2). Mbatha v. Cutting is one such recent case that grapples with conflict of laws pertaining to divorce and division of matrimonial property when the spouses are domiciled in separate jurisdictions. In this case, the Georgian Court of Appeal dealt with competing claims from a couple who married in New York and had their matrimonial domicile in South Africa. The wife, domiciled in Georgia, USA, argued for the application of the matrimonial property regime of South Africa – their only (though temporary) common matrimonial domicile. In determining the applicable law, the Court upheld the traditional approach, which favours lex situs for real property and lex domicilii for personal property.
Views and News from the 9th Journal of Private International Law Conference 2023 in Singapore
Four years after the 8th JPIL conference in Munich, the global community of PIL scholars finally got another opportunity to exchange thoughts and ideas, this time at Singapore Management University on the kind invitation of our co-editor Adeline Chong.
The conference was kicked off by a keynote speech by Justice Philip Jeyaretnam (Singapore International Commercial Court), providing an in-depth analysis of the Court of Appeal’s decision in Anupam Mittal v Westbridge Ventures II [2023] SGCA 1 (discussed in more detail here).
The keynote was followed by a total of 23 panels and four plenary sessions, a selection of which is summarised below by our editors.
The EU Sustainability Directive and Jurisdiction
The Draft for a Corporate Sustainable Due Diligence Directive currently contains no rules on jurisdiction. This creates inconsistencies between the scope of application of the Draft Directive and existing jurisdictional law, both on the EU level and on the domestic level, and can lead to an enforcement gap: EU companies may be able to escape the existing EU jurisdiction; non-EU companies may even not be subject to such jurisdiction. Effectivity requires closing that gap, and we propose ways in which this could be achieved.
(authored by Ralf Michaels and Antonia. Sommerfeld and crossposted at https://eapil.org/)
- The Proposal for a Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence
The process towards an EU Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive is gaining momentum. The EU Commission published a long awaited Proposal for a Directive on Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence (CSDDD), COM(2022) 71 final, on 23 February 2022; the EU Council adopted its negotiation position on 1 December 2022; and now, the EU Parliament has suggested amendments to this Draft Directive on 1 June 2023. The EU Parliament has thereby backed the compromise textreached by its legal affairs committee on 25 April 2023. This sets off the trilogue between representatives of the Parliament, the Council and the Commission.
News
Call for Papers: Special Issue of the Akdeniz University Faculty of Law Journal in Honor of Peter Hay
Necla Ozturk (Editor of the Akdeniz University Faculty of Law Journal) has kindly shared the following call for papers with us:
On the occasion of the 90th birthday of distinguished legal scholar Professor Dr. Peter Hay, Akdeniz University Faculty of Law Journal is preparing a special issue to be published in 2025, dedicated to his outstanding contributions to Private International Law and Comparative Law.
Throughout his illustrious academic career, Professor Hay has profoundly influenced the field through his pioneering work on the relationships between American, German, and European Private Law systems. His publications, teaching, and international engagements have left a lasting mark on the legal world.
We would be honored to receive a contribution from you for this commemorative issue. We especially welcome articles that address topics aligned with Professor Hay’s areas of expertise or offer critical reflections inspired by his scholarly legacy.
Suggested Topics Include:
• Private International Law
• Comparative Law
• Convergence/Divergence of Legal Systems
• American And European Private Law
• Critical Assessments of Professor Hay’s WorkSubmission Deadline: November 15, 2025
Languages Accepted: Turkish, English, German, French.
Submission Guidelines: https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/akdhfd/writing-rulesPlease submit your article via https://dergipark.org.tr/en/pub/akdhfd or hukukdergi@akdeniz.edu.tr by the deadline indicated above.
We look forward to your valuable contribution to this special issue that pays tribute to Professor Peter Hay’s scholarly achievements and influence.
Out Now: Elgar Concise Encyclopedia of International Commercial Arbitration
Despite all recent efforts from the HCCH 2019 Judgments Convention to the founding of International Commercial Courts (ICC) promoting the attractiveness of court litigation, the most favoured method for resolving international disputes in civil and commercial matters, without a single doubt, remains arbitration. According to the 2025 QMUL International Arbitration Survey an overwhelming majority of respondents (87%) would choose international arbitration either as a standalone mechanism (39%) or in combination with other mechanisms of alternative dispute resolution (48%). Read more
Mediating Across Borders: A Guide to Cross-Border Family Dispute Resolution by Costanza Honorati and Ester di Napoli
In response to the growing complexity of cross-border family disputes – driven by increasing mobility and evolving family configurations – the recently published Guida alla mediazione familiare internazionale in materia di responsabilita genitoriale e sottrazione internazionale di minori, authored by Costanza Honorati and Ester di Napoli (Pacini Editore, 2025; available online in open access, in Italian), offers a rigorous and thematically cohesive guide to the law and practice of cross-border family mediation. Grounded in both European and multilateral legal instruments, the volume brings together doctrinal precision, procedural clarity, and practical insight, establishing itself as an essential reference for legal practitioners, judges, mediators, and scholars navigating the intricate terrain of cross-border family justice. Read more